Login | Register | Subscribe to the GG RSS Feed

Are Lonely Planet Books Still Trustworthy?

1
2
3
4
5
GG Staff | 04/14/2008 - 09:18 | 1 comment

Which guidebooks should you read?

We're in shock after a Lonely Planet guidebook writer admitted that he made up information for the famous guides. The quirky guidebooks are proudly promoted because of their "untarnished" journalistic integrity. "If it's in the guidebook our authors have been there."

Searching for AnswersSearching for AnswersThomas Kohnstamm wrote about Chile, the Caribbean, and other South and Central American countries. According to his book Do Travel Writers Go to Hell, he copied information from other guides, dealt drugs for extra cash and even made up details when necessary.

According to folks at Lonely Planet, his reprehensible behavior is completely against company policy, and all the guides he worked on (at least the ones that are still in print) are being thoroughly fact-checked. They reassure readers that his big talk about Columbia isn't so bad after all:

"Thomas has claimed that he was not paid enough to travel to Colombia when he was employed as an author on our Colombia guide. The fact is that Thomas was not employed as an on-the-ground author on that guidebook. This means that he did not write any reviews - of places or establishments - in this book. His contribution was to the introductory chapter covering history, culture, food and drink and environment. "

If this could happen to Lonely Planet...which guidebook can you trust? We don't think this is a matter of Lonely Planet being the underpaying slave drivers that their ex-author is alleging. There are bad apples everywhere.

The fact is, so far the Lonely Planet haven't been able to turn up errors in their fact checking, so Kohnstamm was either lucky, or he's lying about how much he lied.

I'd continue to trust the Lonely Planet, but I use guidebooks in pairs, or with information I find online. Online sources like Restaurantica, Trip Advisor and Go Girlfriend let you find reviews that matter to you. And guidebooks are good general guides.

 

Will you trust Lonely Planet after this scandal?

Related Stories

2007 Top Travel Stories
7 New Airline Websites We Love
Google Street View - Prepare Yourself for Big Brother
Healthy Dining Finder - The Best Places to Eat in North America
Top 25 US Cities for Women
Haunted Historic Hotels

Rate This Post

Average: 1 (1 vote)

Bookmark This Post

  • Delicious
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Magnoliacom
  • Newsvine
  • Furl
  • Facebook
  • Google
  • Yahoo
  • Technorati

Comments

I totally agree with you. I

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/15/2008 - 16:37.
I totally agree with you. I think I my trust in LP has definitely depleted after this. I like to travel mostly, now, with information I get off the internet. I like vivatravelguides.com, plus they sometimes even publish their info from the internet into books. Mostly, I just hope this author doesn't get any rewards from this book and taking advantage LP.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Copy the characters (respecting upper/lower case) from the image.
Register

Membership is free and with it you can set up a profile, vote on stories and post your opinions.

Already a member?
Login
Not a member? Join!
Register

Most Recent Comments

  • On Canada Goes Green for St. Patrick's Day, Julia Rosien said "Great to meet you as well, Terri. And yes, we adore the Bay of Fundy :-) While I'll agree it's no longer parka weather in your neck of the woods, it's not quite string bikini weather either. Shall we toast to it and let the beer warm us up? Happy St Paddy's Day! Julia"

  • On Canada Goes Green for St. Patrick's Day, Terri said "hey Travel girls, great to hear that you love our Bay of Fundy here on the east coast of Canada as much as you love Tim Horton's ...and, as a Bay of Fundy chick, I love the green tide analogy. For sure, there will be lots of fun times down here around St Paddy's day but I just want to send you a correction to say you certainly won't be needing a parka? to visit at this time of year. It's +8 to +10 degress Celius (that's in the 50s F for our American friends) - definitely well above parka weather. haha So nice that the birds are chirping and the maple sap is flying out of the trees and, ultimately, on to our pancakes. Happy spring! Terri the Bay of Fundy blogger bayoffundy.blogspot.com "

  • On Bonaire - Landsailing or Diving, Ann Phelan said "I love when folks visit our island and immerse themselves in the very cool diversions offered..thanks for sharing."

  • On Tour Bus Crash in Tortola – Caribbean Princess Passenger Dies, Sad and heavy heart said "On a note about the roads of Totrola which are steep, and windy and narrow, all the more reason that tour vehicles should have regular safety checks, SEATBELTS (which dirvers should mandate use or not allow passengers to continue with the tour, driver's should go slow, and Princess Cruise Lines should do extensive background checks, and not hire people with the nick-name of Crash-Dummy."

  • On Tour Bus Crash in Tortola – Caribbean Princess Passenger Dies, Jan said "We were also on the ship with our friends, had spent the day at the beach in Tortola where the slider on my Omega came off, "broke" and lost. I had just purchased it on board the ship the day prior. But nothing can compare to the loss of a family member. The Captain had everyones attention for the announcement. Captain Draper done a great job informing the passengers of the accident. Our thoughts and prayers are with the Rumphrey family."