Login | Register | Subscribe to the GG RSS Feed

Are Lonely Planet Books Still Trustworthy?

Which guidebooks should you read?

We're in shock after a Lonely Planet guidebook writer admitted that he made up information for the famous guides. The quirky guidebooks are proudly promoted because of their "untarnished" journalistic integrity. "If it's in the guidebook our authors have been there."

Searching for AnswersSearching for AnswersThomas Kohnstamm wrote about Chile, the Caribbean, and other South and Central American countries. According to his book Do Travel Writers Go to Hell, he copied information from other guides, dealt drugs for extra cash and even made up details when necessary.

According to folks at Lonely Planet, his reprehensible behavior is completely against company policy, and all the guides he worked on (at least the ones that are still in print) are being thoroughly fact-checked. They reassure readers that his big talk about Columbia isn't so bad after all:

"Thomas has claimed that he was not paid enough to travel to Colombia when he was employed as an author on our Colombia guide. The fact is that Thomas was not employed as an on-the-ground author on that guidebook. This means that he did not write any reviews - of places or establishments - in this book. His contribution was to the introductory chapter covering history, culture, food and drink and environment. "

If this could happen to Lonely Planet...which guidebook can you trust? We don't think this is a matter of Lonely Planet being the underpaying slave drivers that their ex-author is alleging. There are bad apples everywhere.

The fact is, so far the Lonely Planet haven't been able to turn up errors in their fact checking, so Kohnstamm was either lucky, or he's lying about how much he lied.

I'd continue to trust the Lonely Planet, but I use guidebooks in pairs, or with information I find online. Online sources like Restaurantica, Trip Advisor and Go Girlfriend let you find reviews that matter to you. And guidebooks are good general guides.

 

Will you trust Lonely Planet after this scandal?

Related Stories

Rate This post

Comments

I totally agree with you. I think I my trust in LP has definitely depleted after this. I like to travel mostly, now, with information I get off the internet. I like vivatravelguides.com, plus they sometimes even publish their info from the internet into books. Mostly, I just hope this author doesn't get any rewards from this book and taking advantage LP.

Post new comment




GoGirlfriend Recommendations

Travel Planning

Fodors
Lonely Planet
Frommers

Register

Membership is free and with it you can set up a profile, vote on stories and post your opinions.

Already a member?
Login

Not a member? Join!
Register


Most Recent Comments

  • On 6 Tips to Survive (and Thrive) in Self-Isolation, admin said "Thanks Bat-El for the great tip. We've included your link in our Bonus Ideas from our Community section so others can enjoy. I really enjoyed the Stonehenge tour ... it's on my bucket list!"
  • On 6 Tips to Survive (and Thrive) in Self-Isolation, Bat-El Galor said "My name is Bat-El, and I'm working in collaboration with Travel Trend website. We've recently published a post -"Top 100 virtual tours around the world". After looking at these wonderful tips to survive in self-isolation; It occurred to me that our post could also contribute to your readers with further virtual tours resources. The post includes 100 links to virtual tours and unique experiences around the world. Feel free to check out the link and enjoy your travels ... https://www.trvltrend.com/technology/virtual-tours/ Cheers,"
  • On Cuba Travel ~ 10 Things You Need to Know Before You Go, admin said "Thanks Gordon for the update ... and given most routes to the resorts on the coast are an hour+ and it's Cuban warm, that money for a beverage is a great tip!"
  • On Cuba Travel ~ 10 Things You Need to Know Before You Go, Gordon Mitchell said "Over the last few years The $25 departure tax has been included in your airfare. Make sure you convert your cash at the airport so you can buy a cold beer on the bus on your way to the resort. They will take canadian money but not loonies and toonies. "
  • On Lesbian Adventure Travel, Debbie Clarke said "If you're considering New Zealand, then New Zealand Awaits is lesbian owned and operated (yes I'm the founder, owner, and guide). We run active and not so active tours for lesbians, as well as some LGBTQ mixed trips. We create itineraries for travellers wanting to self drive, and we have private guides. Come see us! "


Blogs We Love

beautiful Vancouver, British ColumbiaCheck out our GoGirlfriend Facebook page to follow us as we seek new adventures and create memories in our own part of the world.








Advertisement