Login | Register | Subscribe to the GG RSS Feed

Phoenix Sued by New Yorkers After Airport Arrest

Who's responsible for unaccompanied passengers?

This story should strike a chord with anyone who has let a vulnerable family member travel alone - the Gotbaum family is suing the city of Phoenix, after Carol Gotbaum (mother of 3) died in police custody following a scuffle at Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport. After she agreed to go to Tucson for an acohol-related rehab program, they put her on a plane in New York. No one knows why, but Carol had to fly alone.

Unfortunately, Carol became belligerent at the Phoenix airport (she was denied boarding to the connecting flight to Tucson). It looks like no one realized that Carol was intoxicated and not in control of her faculties, so she was treated like a disorderly passenger and taken into police custody (where she later died).

Southwest Girls: Swedberg and WilliamsSouthwest Girls: Swedberg and Williams Police involvement at the airport is becoming increasingly common - from the infamous Southwest girls, to drunk soccer players in Europe, almost anyone who acts up on a plane finds themselves dealing with the local forces. It's great for our safety, but what about passengers who need extra help when they fly?

Does anyone with a condition (or addiction) that might cause erratic behaviour need to travel with someone who understands their symptoms? What about a ten year-old boy going to see his grandma, who flips out when he feels threatened by strangers? Of course people who seem dangerous can't stay on board, but is there someone responsible for informing the police of their special needs?

In the Gotbaums' case, "instead of treating Carol as a mentally or physically impaired citizen, the officers immediately subjected her to excessive and unreasonable force." The city responded to allegations by shifting the blame, apparently stating that Carol's husband should never have let her travel alone.

I'm wondering if Carol's family told the airline why she was flying - if so, shouldn't the airline have informed the police she might behave erratically?

Would you let a sick family member fly alone - what if you couldn't afford a second ticket?

Related Stories

Rate This post

Post new comment

GoGirlfriend Recommendations

Travel Planning

Lonely Planet


Membership is free and with it you can set up a profile, vote on stories and post your opinions.

Already a member?

Not a member? Join!

Most Recent Comments

  • On Lesbian Adventure Travel, Debbie Clarke said "If you're considering New Zealand, then New Zealand Awaits is lesbian owned and operated (yes I'm the founder, owner, and guide). We run active and not so active tours for lesbians, as well as some LGBTQ mixed trips. We create itineraries for travellers wanting to self drive, and we have private guides. Come see us! "
  • On Lesbian Adventure Travel, ELLA Travel said "Thanks for the great article!! If you're travelling to Europe check the ELLA International Lesbian Festival (ellafestival.com) and ELLA Travel (ella-travel.com), organising lesbian events and trips! "
  • On 5 Nudist Resorts that Will Blow Your Mind, John Ruze said "Hi Julia, There is a brand new, very popular nudist resort you should think about reporting on in your next article about naturism. It is the New Terra Cotta Clothing Optional Resort and Spa in sunny Palm Springs, California.. The original Terra Cotta Inn was a fantastic nude resort. Repeat guests from around the world stayed there. TCI was sold in Nov 2015 and greatly missed. Well, this July 2017, it was revived at a new location in Palm Springs. The site is HotelTerraCotta.com. Guests are super happy. It's perfect for couples and girlfriend getaways. And Tom and Mary Clare from the original Terra Cotta Inn work with us, so it has the same relaxing, fun feel. "
  • On The Best Naturist Resorts in Ontario, Dennis Wilson said "Love the freedom feeling going nude . 1st time ever was at freedom fields ranch near Tamworth On,Hector & Eyvon are super hosts ,hope to visit this summer but want to learn of more places to visit."
  • On An Open Letter to Hotels Everywhere, Lynn said "I agree on the night light thing. Since hotels have none, I end up keeping the bathroom light on all night with the door ajar. Windows. I understand in the litigious US of A, hotels need to prevent folks from throwing themselves out the windows (or else the hotel could be sued?!!). Ok, fine. But for those of us who dislike A/C and only use it when absolutely necessary, can't we still have the option for some FRESH AIR? There ARE ways to allow windows to open up only so much, while at the same time preventing an entire body from throwing itself out the window. Bedskirts. Am I the only one who gets the skeevies when I see hotel beds with bedskirts that hit the floor? I always had images of food crumbs, bugs, and god only knows what...as being hidden behind that bedskirt. I'd much rather a bedskirt that's at least 2" above the (usually carpetted) floor. Towels. Can't we get nicer towels that don't feel like cardboard? Carpetting. Am I the only one who never walks barefoot in a hotel room ...esp when there's carpet? Blech. I'm sure those things are very rarely cleaned. "

Blogs We Love

beautiful Vancouver, British ColumbiaCheck out our GoGirlfriend Facebook page to follow us as we seek new adventures and create memories in our own part of the world.