Login | Register | Subscribe to the GG RSS Feed

Costa Cruise Ship Disaster

Is it safe to cruise?

On Friday, January 13, Costa Concordia (owned by Carnival Cruise Lines) ran into rocks off the coast of the Italian Island of Giglio. It quickly began taking on water and capsized early Saturday morning. The accident resurrects memories of the sinking of the Titanic and has been called one of the worst cruise ship disasters in modern times.

Costa Cruise Ship DisasterCosta Cruise Ship DisasterIf you're considering a cruise or have already booked, you're not alone if you're questioning the safety of cruising. And it's a fair question to ask. Have cruise lines gotten lazy with safety procedures? Have passengers?

GoGirlfriend will be cruising this winter and we'll be paying close attention to safety procedures. While there's so much about this accident that points to mismanaged and sloppy emergency procedures, we think it's wrong to let one incident taint an entire industry.

Would you cruise after this disaster?

Cruise relaxationCruise relaxationAn opinion tracking website, SodaHead.com, asked readers whether they would now be less likely to cruise. Of those who responded, 25% said yes, 52% said no and 22% said they were not planning to cruise in the first place. Cruise experts across the web are weighing in as well, forcing the cruise industry to take everything about this disaster seriously.

Cruise Critic - Carolyn Spencer Brown

"This is a wake-up call for Costa, most particularly, but also for any line that has slacked off on the nautical rulebook (not to mention those passengers - and we all know one - who brag about evading the muster drill). It's a wake-up call as well for maritime certification organizations, who deem ships and staff procedures in order. And it's our own alert, too. All cruisers shoulder some responsibility for cruising safely."


Costa Cruise Ship Disaster via CNNCosta Cruise Ship Disaster via CNN"Still, no matter how many safety and training protocols are in place, the image of a submerged Costa Concordia will stay burned in people's minds when they decide if they're going to take a cruise, said Jonathan Bricker, a psychologist at the University of Washington. To prevent any decline in bookings, the cruise industry will have to communicate how safe cruising actually is, he added."

Los Angeles Times

Cruise portsCruise ports"When you have 4,000 people, I think you're looking for trouble - an accident waiting to happen," said Francine Dumont, a travel agent at Plaza Travel in Encino who books mostly cruises. She cites crowd panic and, in the case of the Concordia, the confusion of announcements in multiple languages. She said smaller ships tend to attract seasoned passengers who take the drills seriously, rather than "drinking, chittering-chattering and taking pictures of themselves in their life jackets."


"The last thing the industry wants is a disaster like this," says Peter Wild. "So they make tremendous efforts to avoid any such events." He notes cruise lines have a better record than airlines, in terms of deaths per million passengers. The industry will work hard, he says, to learn from its mistakes.

What's your opinion on cruising after this cruise disaster? Will what happened off the coast of Italy affect whether or not you book a cruise this year?


Follow us on Twitter or like us on Facebook and let's start talking!

Related Stories

Rate This post

Post new comment

GoGirlfriend Recommendations

Connect With Us



Membership is free and with it you can set up a profile, vote on stories and post your opinions.

Already a member?

Not a member? Join!

Most Recent Comments

  • On How to Choose a Cruise Ship Cabin on Your Next Cruise, Tinu said "Thank you for this post! I was dragging my feet about going on a cruise. Now that I know there's such a thing as a balcony cabin, I can't wait to book a trip!"
  • On Travel Advice for Visiting a New Country, NJB said "Hi Stacy, great article! Just wanted to say, you can get an international SIM card that works in multiple countries and on cruise ships. They're not quite as cheap as a SIM card from the country you're visiting, but they're cheaper than a roaming plan on your domestic SIM and will save you a lot of time if you're visiting several countries. I got mine from Telestial, which also offers a range of cheap travel phones and other useful products (adapters, etc)."
  • On 8 Reasons Why You Shouldn’t Take a Mediterranean Cruise, Katie said "love, love, LOVE this list! a mediteranean cruise has been on my bucket list for a long time but i'm moving it to the TOP now!!!!!!"
  • On Best Places in the World to Vacation Naked, Larry F. said "Of course you can go to some great clothing optional B&B's in the network of homes in Clothing Optional Home Network! With locations coast to coast plus Mexico and the Caribbean, there must be one near you! All are affiliated with AANR, so you can be assured of a quality clothing optional experience!"
  • On Best Places in the World to Vacation Naked, Lori Jennings said "Florida's Pasco County is the nudist capitol of America and Caliente Resort & Spa is the best place to get naked in Florida. It's for adults only and is clothing optional, so no pressure. But, you can be as you are naturally in a luxury environment. No passport needed and derivable from most states. "

Blogs We Love

beautiful Vancouver, British ColumbiaCheck out our GoGirlfriend Facebook page to follow us as we seek new adventures and create memories in our own part of the world.